I have owned the EdP two times, and both times I swapped it away. I LOVE the scent; I just cant deal with that annoying tuber note, not on my skin anyway. Now the EdT smells just as good and is additionally a step up from the EdP! LOVE it! It is not as creamy with vanilla, the tuber note is plenty strong but somehow sticks out less, and there is a fruitiness to the perfume as (it might just be my chemistry) it smells like green bananas as it wafts up from my wrists. I love the scent of bananas in perfume, so even if it is not intentional by Tom Ford, that is how it shows up on my skin. For this alone, I might have to purchase a bottle. This is my 110% PERFECT version of Black Orchid.